a man working on a water heater

Water Heater Replacement
1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis

  1. Replacement vs. Repair

  2. Choosing a Water Heater

  3. How to Extend Your Water Heater's Lifespan

  4. The Water Heater Replacement Experts

Your water heater is an essential appliance, especially during an intense Indianapolis winter. However, like all appliances, age and usage can take a toll on it. 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis will teach you the signs that you might need a new water heater.

Ready to
Contact us now!

Contact Us

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Replacement vs. Repair

Don't feel like you need to replace your water heater at the first sign of trouble. However, there are definitely circumstances when it makes more sense to replace your system, including:


If your water heater is more than 10 years old, it's best to say goodbye. Even if you've avoided any breakdowns, keeping it could be tempting fate. Sooner or later, it's going to break down, and you'll wish you'd acted sooner.

The older your water heater gets, the more outward signs of struggle it'll display. You'll hear weird sounds and the water will be nowhere as warm as before. 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis can install a great, new water heater for you.

Constant Repair Calls

It's okay to need your water heater fixed a couple of times. However, if it keeps happening, you should just move on. Any further repairs would just be delaying the inevitable.

Avoid problems with a yearly water heater inspection. A technician can also advise you on whether you'd be better off just purchasing a new water heater.

Cracked Tank

Some water heater leaks can be resolved, but not ones from cracked tanks. This happens to older systems, as their parts get worn and their tanks start to rust. There might also be a great deal of sediment at the base, leading to further cracking. Be sure to flush your water heater regularly to remove sediment.

Check around your water heater once a week for any signs of leakage. If necessary, use a wet/dry vac to clean up the water. Shut off the tank completely, cutting off both its water and power supplies. Then, call a professional water heater technician to report the leak and discuss the next steps.

Wrong Size Unit

Hot water is not an infinite resource. This becomes abundantly clear when your unit is too small for your home. At least one person's going to have a cold shower.

A water heater that's too big will provide hot water. However, it's far more than necessary, and your energy bills will shoot up.

Don't guestimate with water heaters. Find a professional company like 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis to help you determine the right size water heater for your home.

Selling Home

About to put your home on the market? What's more likely to sway potential buyers: an old and possibly worn-out water heater, or a newly installed, energy-efficient one? Anything that can save new homeowners a small fortune should be appreciated.

You don't need to replace an otherwise-operational water heater. However, if you're hoping to sell your home and you know your heater is past its prime, get a replacement. You can also save money on your water bills in the interim.

Choosing a Water Heater

Once you've decided you need a new water heater, you need to make sure you choose the right one. Here are some things to consider in your search:

Tank or Tankless?

The prototypical water heater has a giant tank for storing water. However, it's not the only kind. Tankless water heaters do just the same while taking up far less room. They also have greater longevity, twice as long as some tank heaters.

If you've relied on tank water heaters, you might not realize the freedoms of a tankless system. For further information about tankless water heaters, reach out to 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis.


As we mentioned earlier, your water heater needs to be the right size for your home. Don't try to save money by purchasing a too-small water heater. Alternately, don't waste money with one that's too large.

Pay attention to the first hour rating (FHR) of any water heater you're considering. This is how much hot water a given unit can produce in an hour (in gallons). Determine how much hot water you use in a typical week, considering different activities like showering and washing clothes. Look for a water heater FHR that will fulfill your needs.

Electric vs. Gas

There's no outright consensus for which is better, electric or gas water heaters. However, it's still good to examine the benefits and drawbacks of each one. Gas water heaters are more expensive at first, but electric water heaters are more expensive to maintain. Conversely, you shouldn't get a gas water heater if you don't already have a gas setup.

Tankless water heaters also come in gas and electric models. Keep in mind that gas ones can operate on either natural gas or through propane. Make sure you're clear about what yours runs on.

Energy Efficiency

Heating water takes up a massive amount of energy. Look for a more energy-efficient water heater, one with ENERGY STAR certification. Read reviews to see if other customers saw noticeable declines in energy bills.

This is one of the best arguments for a tankless water heater. Instead of constantly warming up the water, regardless of demand, you'll get hot water exactly when you need it. Call 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis to learn more about how a tankless water heater could help you.


Outside opinions are a must when looking for a water heater. Check out reviews for water heaters on trusted sources like Consumer Reports. If you know someone who recently had one installed, ask them about it and if they'd recommend it.

Don't make any decisions until you've had some professional consultation. If you're considering a water heater, call 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis for further discussion. We'll help you determine the perfect water heater for your home.

First plumber we called wanted $3500.00 to replace everything. Emanuel came out and suggested we change one part and less than $300.00 later we was up and running again. From Mark, to Taylor, and then on to Emanuel the whole experience was professional and I will be a customer for life. Hopefully not often though. Great working with you guys!.


Positive: Professionalism , Punctuality , Quality New hot water heater installed same day as estimate. Very friendly and quick. Very thorough explaining everything. read less

Satisfied Customer

EMANUEL REYES IS GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kathleen E.

Excellent work by all, starting with the ease of making an appointment, the arrival of the service crew in a timely manner. They were on neatly dressed, very pleasant, explained everything and took the little extra steps to make the visit a success. I have used this plumber three times now and have always had exceptional service from them.

Jan C.

Joesph came out right on time. Showed me what my issue was, and told me my options (very professional). This company is fair and honest! They don't try to up sale or over price their product or service.. I highly recommend 1-800-Plumer of Pearland!! Go with these guys and you won't be disappointed!

Terril Kelly

I think there the best

Michael D.

Kyle provided excelleent service as he always does. I have had some tricky plumbing problems and he has always solved the problem with efficient service and winning personality. He did a beautiful job on my pipe. He takes a lot of pride in his work .

Ruth L.

Chad C. with 1-800-plumber really cared. He was extremely thorough and made sure the job was done correctly. Would definitely recommend him!

Kathy Y.

Joey and Moses came out to replace a waterline and were AWESOME!!! They answered my questions, where patient, friendly (respectful) and VERY professional! This my 2nd time using 1800 plumber and both visits were great! I look forward to continue using them! read less

Satisfied Customer

On time, fast working, and did a great job

Michael R.

Availability icon



costs at the end of a job icon

No surprise

costs at the end of a job

Committed to on-time arrivals icon


Committed to on-time arrivals

How to Extend Your Water Heater’s Lifespan

It's satisfying to replace your water heater, but you won't want to do it again anytime soon. These are some ways you can extend its lifespan.

Yearly Maintenance

Schedule a water heater inspection every year. Do this regardless of if you think anything is wrong with it. An inspection can help you save money - and possibly your life.

A visit and tune-up can improve overall operating power, which can help you save money on energy. A technician can also catch a possible carbon monoxide leak coming from your gas heater. It's best to hire the same company for maintenance as you do for installation. 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis provides both.


Earlier we talked about sediment accumulation in water heaters and why it's important to flush it out regularly. Don't feel too intimidated by this. Flushing your water heater is actually a fairly simple, and even enjoyable, process.

You'll need to turn off your cold water, hook up a hose to your heater's drain valve, run hot water, and open the drain valve, seeing how the water looks after at least two drainings. It's crucial to follow all of the steps in order. Watch videos on flushing water heaters for more information, or call 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis.

Water Softener Installation

Hard water comes from an excess of minerals in your water. As you know this can cause damage to your water heater. A water softener can help you lower your water's overall hardness.

You should feel the benefits of a water softener as you go about your routine. It's much easier on your hair and skin, leading to more satisfying showers and a better overall appearance. It can also lower your energy bills through greater efficiency and keep your clothes and dishes from staining.

Expansion Tank Installation

Water heaters create significant pressure when operating, and that needs to go somewhere. Too much pressure can be harmful to the heater, as well as other plumbing components. That's why you should purchase an expansion tank for your water heater.

Check to see if your water supply has a check valve. If so, you need an expansion tank, because the pressure will otherwise stay within your home, causing potential long-term damage. Hire a professional plumbing service like 1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis to install your expansion tank. We'll make sure it's the right size for your water heater and that it's properly installed.

The Water Heater Replacement Experts

1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis can help you find the perfect new water heater. Whether you want a gas or electric, a tank or tankless system, we're here for you. Contact us today about any other questions or to schedule an appointment.


We know your time is valuable. Select the day and time that you would prefer and we will contact you to confirm this appointment. We look forward to meeting your needs!

Serving Indianapolis, IN and the Surrounding Areas

1-800-Plumber +Air of Indianapolis
5222 S East St B-4
Indianapolis, IN 46227

Our Service Area Cities:
Beech Grove, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Camby, West Newton.

Our Service Area Zip Codes:
46107 46142 46143 46203 46204 46227 46237 46239 46259 46113 46183 46214 46217 46221 46222 46224 46225 46231 46234 46241 46282 46201 46202 46205 46208 46218 46219 46226 46229 46235.